AI VIDEO QUALITY

One maker, one reviewer, one approver

Agents that can all give orders will undo each other. Give each job to exactly one place, write the rules down, and let only the owner say go.

Figure 1: One maker agent, one reviewer, and the owner who approves. Arrows show the brief, the episode and the fix list.

1. Three jobs, three places

RoleDoesDoes not
Maker (one agent)Makes stills, animates them, checks each take, assembles, delivers with a change log.Start an episode without the owner’s go. Take orders from other agents.
Reviewer (one agent plus the tools)Locks the shot script, runs every check, writes the fix list, confirms each fix landed.Approve on the owner’s behalf.
Approver (the owner)Says go, watches the finished episode with sound, approves or sends back.Check frames by eye. The tools and the reviewer do that.

In the first attempt three agents could all direct production. The result was churn. After the change, a fix list sent at lunchtime came back the same afternoon as a corrected episode with a change log, and the owner’s verdict on it was “far better, no issues”.

2. Write the standing rules down once

The maker gets a short standing-rules file that applies to every episode. Ours covers: runtime windows and how to hit them by trimming; the reference pack; the nine mistakes not to repeat (dissolves, silence, blank backgrounds, wrong hands, unscripted writing, props that change size, fallen things standing up, strangers walking in, clipped titles); one episode at a time; and a usage check before each one.

When a new kind of mistake shows up, it becomes a new line in that file, not a new conversation.

3. The go line, and scheduled runs

Agents in this project would not start paid work without the owner’s own words in their chat. That is a good rule. Keep it, and make the go line explicit: “Go on episode 2. Follow the standing rules. Post usage first.”

Watch for scheduled jobs. The maker had set itself a timer to start four episodes at once. Before any episode starts, ask the maker to list its scheduled routines, and pause anything that runs ahead of the fixes.

Layman rule: One place makes, one place checks, one person decides. Everyone else may advise.

4. Messages worth keeping as templates

  • Start: “Go on [episode]. Follow the standing rules. Post weekly usage first.”
  • Fix: “Here is the fix list. Fix every MUST and SHOULD, leave the CHECK items, deliver the next version with a change log.”
  • Approve: “[Episode] version [n] is approved.”
  • Stop: “Stop all generation now and wait.”